lthough those of us who have had long careers in the community
college sector of higher education have seen many changes,
one thing has remained constant-our core mission of providing
access to higher education to underserved student populations
in our service regions. Thankfully, our understanding of
this mission has evolved. In the early 1970s, community college
leaders equated this notion of access to simply offering open
enrollment degree and certificate programs. Everyone with a
high school diploma or GED had a right to enroll in a community
college and had "the right to fail." Fortunately, we have moved
well beyond this viewpoint and most community colleges now
minimally define assess to higher education as access to a reasonable
opportunity for each student to achieve his, or her,
educational goals.
In addition to an innate desire to support student learning and
goal attainment, community college leaders are also under increasing
pressure from federal, state, and local government entities
and regional accrediting associations to measure, document,
and publish their student achievement rates and student
learning outcomes. While we understand and accept our responsibility
to be accountable to our funding sources, accrediting
bodies, and our students, we are concerned that the measures
often suggested, such as graduation rates, are inappropriate
in our open enrollment educational setting.
Over the years, community college researchers have worked
diligently to gain a better understanding of our students' educational
goals as well as their academic and student support
needs-to identify what works and what does not work to help
our students succeed. Our college faculty and staff have used
this research to develop and implement an array of academic
programs and support services designed to maximize student
achievement. Unfortunately, few community college faculty or
staff would say that they are satisfied with the student success
levels achieved. Too many of our students do not achieve their
educational goals, and an achievement gap continues to exist
for some minority student populations.
To improve student success rates, community college researchers
need to help community college faculty and staff identify
better models and resources to assess student learning outcomes
at the curricular and co-curricular levels and measure
their institutional impact on improving student achievement on
our campuses. We need to build the capacity to compare our
student outcomes on the program and support service levels to
institutional peers in order to identify potential best practices
for our individual college settings. We need to identify sensible
student goal attainment measures that reflect the diversity of
our students' entering academic skill levels and the complexity
of their lives. The fulfillment of this research agenda is essential
to achieving our mission of providing true access to higher
education and a reasonable opportunity for success to our students.
A few focus areas for community colleges researchers
that would contribute to the achievement of this goal include
the following:
Identify better ways to track and measure student goal attainment.
Pinpoint significant student transition points, in addition
to graduation and transfer, to monitor student progress.
Examples may include the completion of developmental
course work; movement into and completion of college level
writing and mathematics courses; and the achievement of
sufficient technical proficiency to secure employment in
their field of interest prior to degree completion.
Identify courses, portions of courses, or college experiences
that function as gatekeepers to goal attainment - the point
where many students, or certain student cohort groups,
drop out or fail-and analyze the contributing factors.
Define appropriate measures of community college student
goal attainment that colleges can use to compare their outcomes
to institutional peers.
Develop and institutionalize research strategies to measure
the equity of student goal attainment and outcomes by race,
gender, age, and income level and to analyze underlying
factors contributing to any inequities identified.
Student success is a campus-wide responsibility. Community
college researchers, faculty, and staff need to work
collaboratively to define measurements of student attainment
and student learning outcomes that we can agree are appropriate
in our educational setting, widely accepted by our community
college colleagues, and routinely collected and available to
community college practitioners. We also need to work together
to create better ways to compare institutional student learning
outcomes and student achievement rates to those achieved by
institutional peers; measure the effectiveness of individual student
and academic support services to improve student achievement;
and assess the capacity of academic programs and support
services to achieve equitable student outcomes across gender,
race, age, and income lines. All of our talents, energies, and
perspectives are needed to truly fulfill our mission of providing
access and success in higher education for all of our students.
Dr. Lois Alves is Vice President of Enrollment Management at Middlesex
Community College in Lowell, MA. She can be reached at alvesl@middlesex.mass.edu.
Office of Community College Research and Leadership | University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
51 Gerty Drive, 129 CRC | Champaign, IL 61820
phone: 217-244-9390 | fax: 217-244-0851 | e-mail:occrl@uiuc.edu